Joined: 22 Jul 2006 Posts: 7637 Birthday: 7th July
Location: Shropshire
Posted: Tue Jul 31, 2007 2:34 pm Post subject: Review The Vanishing Act of Esme Lennox by Maggie O'Farrell
We've got 4 copies of The Vanishing Act of Esme Lennox by Maggie O'Farrell for review. If you'd like to review and receive a copy of the book, please PM Glynis for details.
Pleased about this as have it on my tbr. I loved her book, After You'd Gone. Such a moving story.
Joined: 11 Apr 2007 Posts: 459 Birthday: 22nd April
Location: Devon
Posted: Tue Jul 31, 2007 9:38 pm Post subject:
This one sounds interesting too-sorry, am I being very greedy asking for two? I am, I know .
I should have read all the posts before getting carried away
Joined: 22 Jul 2006 Posts: 7637 Birthday: 7th July
Location: Shropshire
Posted: Fri Aug 17, 2007 9:28 pm Post subject:
Not at all Elaine!! Hope you're enjoying the books _________________ Reading: Miss Smilla's Feeling for Snow by Peter Hoeg
Reading Challenge 2009: 8
2008: 4
2007: 10
Joined: 11 Apr 2007 Posts: 459 Birthday: 22nd April
Location: Devon
Posted: Sat Aug 18, 2007 12:12 pm Post subject:
Am very pleasantly impressed with "Wicked", which is quite different to what I expected. Should have it finished and reviewed by tomorrow.
Haven't read much at all this week. Friends knowing that I've been doggy nursing, have been popping in regularly-so lots of chat and not much reading done!
Joined: 22 Jul 2006 Posts: 955 Birthday: 12th December
Location: Paisley, Scotland
Posted: Sat Aug 18, 2007 12:17 pm Post subject:
Hi Glynis
I think I would like to review this. It was recommended to me yesterday by a collegue and it looks like something I would like. I can pay be paypal, or send a chq or stamps - just let me know what to do! _________________ Currently reading: The Human Stain by Philip Roth
'Our deepest fear is not that we are inadequate. Our deepest fear is that we are powerful beyond measure.'
Joined: 22 Jul 2006 Posts: 7637 Birthday: 7th July
Location: Shropshire
Posted: Sat Aug 18, 2007 1:23 pm Post subject:
Thanks Miranda - I'll send you a copy and PM you with the details. _________________ Reading: Miss Smilla's Feeling for Snow by Peter Hoeg
Reading Challenge 2009: 8
2008: 4
2007: 10
Joined: 22 Jul 2006 Posts: 7637 Birthday: 7th July
Location: Shropshire
Posted: Sun Aug 19, 2007 10:46 am Post subject:
Here is Mandy J's review of The Vanishing Act of Esme Lennox:
(Thanks, Mandy! )
The Vanishing Act of Esme Lennox tells the story of a young woman whose free spirit, unconventional behaviour and inability or unwillingness to conform to the rules of polite society cause her family to send her to Cauldstone, a grim mental institution – a practice all too common in earlier times, when “difficult” or eccentric women could thus be easily hidden away. Esme remains abandoned there for 60 years until the institution’s imminent closure leads it to contact her great-niece Iris, who apparently is responsible for her great-aunt, as Esme’s only other surviving relative , her sister Kitty, suffers form Alzheimer’s.
Iris has never heard of Esme, but when she realises the only alternative accommodation is a seedy hostel, feels impelled to take care of her and takes her back to her flat – in the very house where Esme and Kitty lived as young women. As family secrets begin to be uncovered, the story moves towards its inexorable and tragic end.
This is a very enjoyable and highly readable novel. Maggie O’Farrell writes well and handles the disjointed narrative and the use of different voices to tell the story expertly and effectively. However, there were some serious flaws to the book, the main one being the contrast between Esme’s poignant and heart-rending story and Iris’s altogether less convincing one. Iris’s affair with a married man is not only extraneous to the plot and adds nothing to our understanding of Esme’s plight but is also clichéd and clumsily handled. And although the plot device of Iris’s feelings for her step-brother Alex can be somewhat better justified, reflecting as it does the secrets that beset this family, as a story it is simply not engaging enough and some of the impact of Esme’s tragic tale is lessened by the focus on Iris and her less important issues.
It would have been nice as well to know more about Esme’s thoughts and feelings as she negotiated not only her 60 years’ incarceration but also her unexpected freedom. There is no mention of any curiosity about the world she is released into, yet the world after 60 years is inevitably very different to the one she left behind. Perhaps this is meant to convey that there is only one thought dominating Esme’s mind – but if so this is not demonstrated clearly enough.
And the ending is too abrupt. Alex and Iris’s conversation in the car park whilst the dénouement takes place “off-stage” actually detracts from the drama being played out in Kitty’s room. And with a rather unconvincing and sentimental last line, the book seems to peter out rather than shock us.
Nevertheless, and in spite of these criticisms, it is an essentially moving and enjoyable book, well worth reading - but perhaps one that doesn’t benefit from too critical an examination. An excellent book group choice, however, as I am sure there are bound to be plenty of different opinions! _________________ Reading: Miss Smilla's Feeling for Snow by Peter Hoeg
Reading Challenge 2009: 8
2008: 4
2007: 10
Joined: 11 Feb 2007 Posts: 2509 Birthday: 19th July
Location: Dorset, UK
Posted: Mon Aug 20, 2007 5:59 pm Post subject:
I shouldn't really as I'm trying to get TBR down but I keep looking at this book and would love to read and review it so I guess I would like a copy if there is still one available. Let me know how much you want for postage and the easiest way for me to pay you (I do have paypal but not sure if fees make it not the best way).
Joined: 22 Jul 2006 Posts: 7637 Birthday: 7th July
Location: Shropshire
Posted: Mon Aug 20, 2007 6:49 pm Post subject:
Hi Sarah - think I have one copy of the book left. Will check and get back to you by PM. _________________ Reading: Miss Smilla's Feeling for Snow by Peter Hoeg
Reading Challenge 2009: 8
2008: 4
2007: 10
Joined: 22 Jul 2006 Posts: 7637 Birthday: 7th July
Location: Shropshire
Posted: Tue Aug 28, 2007 9:52 am Post subject:
This is Elaine's review (thanks again Elaine!):
"The Vanishing Act of Esme Lennox"
How often do we read a novel, enjoy it, with a slight “but”, along the lines of “great, but a bit long”? Here we find the opposite-”great, but a bit short”-indeed, there is scope for a sequel, so I hope in time the author returns to the fascinating theme, and heart-warming characters.
Stylistically this is a novel which works extremely well, with the switching of time periods and narrator, being particularly appropriate. Overall it is a novel of contrasts-Esme’s suffering against Iris’s rather easy lifestyle; life in colonial India as opposed to a middle class life in Edinburgh. This type of compare and contrast worked extremely well, and highlighted Esme’s plight very effectively:
“Esme knows the girl-this girl who has appeared from nowhere and after so long-has done her best. Esme does realise this, and she wonders for a moment if there is a way to communicate it. Probably not”.
The characterisation is superb, and whist we always empathise with Esme(even as a child, she seemed to have a hard life, with her mother showing very little interest in her), as the novel unfolds, our initial irritation with Iris, also changes, to a tacit understanding that she too, has had experiences which have scarred her. While Iris’s infatuation with Luke is doomed to failure, she shows an immensely compassionate streak in her early dealings with Esme. The tenderness and protectiveness she displays in difficult circumstances make her a much more appealing character than she appears early in the novel.
There are few light moments in the novel-but they do exist, demonstrating the author’s talents are not limited to characterisation! For example, the episode when the girls were taken shopping, after their arrival in Edinburgh was a brief and amusing contrast to their accustomed lifestyle-their awe was almost tangible, and gave the novel one of it’s few light-hearted moments.
The plot, and family secrets are predictable, but the strength of the novel lies in the creation of these two very vivid and unforgettable characters. A quick read, but highly recommended. Gripping, subtle and immensely moving. _________________ Reading: Miss Smilla's Feeling for Snow by Peter Hoeg
Reading Challenge 2009: 8
2008: 4
2007: 10
Joined: 14 Apr 2007 Posts: 309 Birthday: 11th April
Location: Cheltenham
Posted: Fri Sep 07, 2007 1:43 am Post subject:
Have just requested this on RISI. If it's not successful is there a spare copy floating around anywhere I can get my mitts on? Many thanks _________________ My Swap List
Currently reading: Other people's children - Joanna Trollope
Challenge books read: 5
Joined: 22 Jul 2006 Posts: 7637 Birthday: 7th July
Location: Shropshire
Posted: Fri Sep 07, 2007 10:15 am Post subject:
I don't have any left, but once I've read mine you're welcome to borrow/have it!! _________________ Reading: Miss Smilla's Feeling for Snow by Peter Hoeg
Reading Challenge 2009: 8
2008: 4
2007: 10
Joined: 11 Feb 2007 Posts: 2509 Birthday: 19th July
Location: Dorset, UK
Posted: Sat Sep 08, 2007 7:46 am Post subject:
Well I thought this was a great book, quite light but thought provoking. I read it in 2 days!
As has been said, the two time periods in this book work well together, contrasting the different lives of colonial India and modern Britain. I understand the comment about wanting to know more about Esme's thoughts on her life in the institution and her "new" life but the absence of this highlights for me the fact that she has never been allowed to express her own opinion, either as a child or an adult. She was always merely expected to conform, and failing to do so it what got her where she is.
I particularly like the style used for the thoughts of Esme's sister who has Alzheimers. The author writes a few lines and then stops abruptly, as though the character has lost their train of thought, leaving the reader to fill in the gap.
Joined: 22 Jul 2006 Posts: 7637 Birthday: 7th July
Location: Shropshire
Posted: Sat Sep 08, 2007 8:25 am Post subject:
Oh Sarah you should read After You've Gone by Maggie O'Farrell. I read it about 10 years ago and it had me reaching for the tissues every page! I loved it. _________________ Reading: Miss Smilla's Feeling for Snow by Peter Hoeg
Reading Challenge 2009: 8
2008: 4
2007: 10
Joined: 14 Apr 2007 Posts: 309 Birthday: 11th April
Location: Cheltenham
Posted: Sat Sep 08, 2007 10:50 am Post subject:
Agree with Glynis, 'After you'd gone' is fantastic. I also enjoyed 'The distance between us' but have to say I didn't like 'My Lover's Lover'. _________________ My Swap List
Currently reading: Other people's children - Joanna Trollope
Challenge books read: 5
Joined: 22 Jul 2006 Posts: 7637 Birthday: 7th July
Location: Shropshire
Posted: Sun Oct 14, 2007 1:27 pm Post subject:
Here is Miranda's review of the book:
Spoiler:
The Vanishing Act of Esme Lennox’ is a novel about three generations of women, and set between two different time zones. It flickers between the present day and the polite society circles of the 1930s. Dealing mostly with the treatment of women in the 1930s, it contrasts the present day freedom of women with the mould that women were forced to fill 70 years ago. It tells the story of Esme, locked up in an asylum because of her refusal to conform to social conventions, her sister, who is so deceived by the promise of social conventions that she would stop at nothing to have the perfect life she covets only to be disappointed and Iris, a young woman facing the modern problem of loving the wrong people. Since the character of Esme is about 80 years old the novel highlights the fact that there are women alive today that have lived through the type of treatment Esme suffered. It shows that today’s women can now; live alone, own their own companies, have affairs, and is perhaps serving as a reminder that a lot of what we take for granted was hard fought for by others, and that we should be carrying forward their efforts and not becoming complacent about the treatment of women all around the world. I enjoyed this novel because it dealt with an unusual subject matter and made me more aware of this part of our history. I cared about the characters of Iris and Esme, and I wondered what I would do if I was faced with the decisions they had to make. I also liked the flashback structure of the novel which let the story unravel slowly – mirroring Esme’s life. I felt there were a lot of loose ends; however this seems fitting as it made the novel seem more like real-life and left the reader to think about the different outcomes that are possible. Overall, I thought this novel was enjoyable and thought-provoking.
Thank you Miranda _________________ Reading: Miss Smilla's Feeling for Snow by Peter Hoeg
Reading Challenge 2009: 8
2008: 4
2007: 10
Joined: 14 Apr 2007 Posts: 309 Birthday: 11th April
Location: Cheltenham
Posted: Fri Mar 21, 2008 11:16 am Post subject:
Glynis wrote:
I don't have any left, but once I've read mine you're welcome to borrow/have it!!
Hi Glynis, thanks for this offer but my boss lent me this last week, reading it and enjoying it now! Will post my thoughts on here once finished. _________________ My Swap List
Currently reading: Other people's children - Joanna Trollope
Challenge books read: 5
Joined: 22 Jul 2006 Posts: 7637 Birthday: 7th July
Location: Shropshire
Posted: Fri Mar 21, 2008 4:04 pm Post subject:
Hope you enjoy it Jen. Btw, agree with you about My Lover's Lover; I didn't think it as good as After You'd Gone. _________________ Reading: Miss Smilla's Feeling for Snow by Peter Hoeg
Reading Challenge 2009: 8
2008: 4
2007: 10
Joined: 11 Feb 2007 Posts: 2509 Birthday: 19th July
Location: Dorset, UK
Posted: Fri Mar 21, 2008 6:29 pm Post subject:
I read My Lovers Lover too and wasn't particularly impressed. The idea was ok but it didn't seem to work that well when written, it just didn't gel together for me. Nor did I like the main character!!
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum